Every family historian has their brick walls. We collect certificates, search newspapers, pore over DNA matches and build theories from fragments of evidence. Yet there are some questions that only the people themselves could answer.
If I could speak to ghosts, there are three ancestors in particular I would love to spend an evening with.
Roseana Jones (1872- 1915)
My first question would be simple: "Who is your father?"
My paternal great grandmother, Roseana Jones (nee Atkins) was born in Dunolly, Victoria in 1872 to unmarried Eliza Atkins. No father was recorded on Roseana's birth certificate. When she married, her father was recorded as Robert Atkins, a man I have never been able to identify. When she died, her father was recorded as John Blain, her stepfather.
More than 150 years later, the mystery remains unsolved.
Family stories suggest her unknown father may have been Aboriginal, but there is no evidence to prove this. DNA testing has not provided any clear answers either.
If I could sit down with Roseana, I would ask whether she knew who her father was, what her mother told her, and whether the stories are even close to the truth. More than that, I would want to know about life and her childhood.
![]() |
| My grandmother denied that there was aboriginal heritage. |
Samuel Francis Drayton (c1814-1901)
![]() |
| It is believed that this is Richard Foy and Charlotte Drayton c1886 We believe that Charlotte has 25% African American ancestry. |
Richard Foy (1848 - 1898)
My maternal great great grandfather, Richard Foy, presents a different mystery.
He was likely born in Tuam, County Galway, in late 1848, while Ireland was experiencing the Great Famine. At some point his family appears to have moved to Lancashire, England, before Richard emigrated to Australia in the 1870s.
Unfortunately, records of his arrival (in Brisbane) seem to have been lost, leaving gaps in his story.
But I would like to know more about the man himself.
After arriving in Australia, Richard formed a relationship with Charlotte, a woman whose husband had deserted her and left her to raise a young son alone. Richard helped support both Charlotte and her child, Samuel. Together they had three children, Agnes, May and John before eventually marrying in October 1893.
Tragically, their young son died of "Asphyxia Congestion of the Lungs" in July 1893, which is about the same time that Charlotte was diagnosed with tuberculosis. She died less than five month later, in December 1893, which was two months after their marriage.
Did Richard marry Charlotte knowing she was dying, wanting to provide security for her and their remaining children? What was life like for them before they married?
Then only three years later Richard married Charlotte's sister Virginia. Was Virginia already helping care for the children who had lost their mother? Was their marriage born from affection, necessity, family loyalty, or perhaps all three?
More tragedy followed. Virginia gave birth to their son Percy on 19 September 1897. Four days later, both Virginia and baby Percy were dead. Virginia's death certificate records pneumonia and heart failure after a short illness, while Percy died from lack of sustenance. By May 1898, Richard himself had also died from pneumonia and typhoid, while returning from Western Australia to Victoria.
If I could talk to Richard, I would ask about his family origins, Ireland, England and the voyage to Australia. But I would also ask about Charlotte, Virginia and the children. How did he find the strength to endure the loss of two children and two wives? Why did he leave the children with their grandparents in Victoria while he went to Western Australia?
Questions without answers
Family history is full of gaps. Some questions refuse to be answered.
There are many ancestors I would love the opportunity to speak with, each carrying stories and answers that have been lost with time. But if I could choose just three ghosts for a conversation, these are the three I would seek out.
I would ask Roseana Jones "Who was your father?"
I would ask Samuel Drayton about his mother, his ancestry, his years aboard the Sophia, and why he chose to begin a new life in Australia.
And I would ask Richard Foy about Ireland, the journey that brought him to Australia, and the tragedies and hardships he endured along the way.
Then I would simply listen. Because sometimes the greatest family history mysteries are not about names and dates. They are about people.
I would love to be able to speak with ghosts!
This post was inspired by Sepia Saturday.



What a great post to match the prompt. I, too, as do many folks, I think, wish there was a way to talk to those who have gone on before us to learn who they really were - what kind of a person they were. I'm very lucky to have not only several photos of my great grandfather, J.K. Smedley, but also have the original journal he kept of his trip to Yosemite in 1874 which gives a bit of insight into his personality - who he was beyond the photos.
ReplyDeleteHow wonderful to have that journal. Have you recreated his journey?
DeleteGenealogy is full of haunting stories, mysteries we hope to find the answer to, and your three stories are perfect for Halloween. Records can tell us so much, but when they are lacking or there is ambiguity, that is where the mystery comes in. I hope you find answers to your thought-provoking questions you've brought us on Halloween.
ReplyDeleteMolly, one of my retirement goals is to write a historical fiction novel but based on the facts as we know them about family. I have many interesting family members to write about, but need to determine how I am going to bring all their stories together in one book!
ReplyDeleteWhat a lovely way to frame these brick walls — as conversations you'd love to have rather than just gaps in the records. Roseana's story stayed with me most: no father on her birth certificate, then Robert Atkins at her marriage and John Blain, her stepfather, at her death, with the family story still unproven after all this time. And Samuel's years aboard the Sophia, with a Philadelphia birth that can't quite be pinned down, feels like exactly the kind of mystery where one answer would unlock ten more. Thank you for sharing these three so honestly — the not-knowing is part of the story too.
ReplyDeleteIf Alan had prizes for Sepia Saturdays, this blog story would win the blue ribbon! You've captured the essence of family research, Sharon, which is asking questions of our ancestors. In ancient times it was preserved in shared memories passed on within family members. Now those tales and pictures are saved in blogs like yours. But the questions only multiply and leave us with even more mysteries that envelope us with silence.
ReplyDeleteThank you Mike. I really appreciate your comments and praise. Other priorities meant that I had a break but realise now the importance of recording my research and notes for future generations. Thanks again.
DeleteI came close on this prompt to featuring my direct ancestors and enjoyed reading your profiles. Good luck in your efforts to solve some of the mysteries about their lives.
ReplyDelete